Skip to main content
ProceedingsFull paper Open access

Open Peer Review of Machine-Learning Papers: Early Evidence

In Proceedings of the International Conference on Open and Reproducible AI Research (OPENAIR 2026), pp. 29–40. Nairobi, Kenya, 19 Oct 2026.

DOI 10.xxxx/ctm.pr.2026.0014 · ID CTM-PR-2026-0014

Download PDF

Cite this record

Mensah, K. & Fernandes, J. (2026). Open Peer Review of Machine-Learning Papers: Early Evidence. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Open and Reproducible AI Research (OPENAIR 2026) (pp. 29–40). CONTINUUM Proceedings. doi:10.xxxx/ctm.pr.2026.0014

Sample record. Fictional demonstration content.

Abstract

We study reports from 300 openly reviewed machine-learning papers. Open reports are longer, more specific and more often cite evidence than comparable anonymous reports from closed venues, and reviewers who sign their reports are no more lenient. We discuss limits of the comparison.

Keywords open peer review · reviewing · transparency

Full text

CTM-PR-2026-0014.pdf

Paper · PDF · pp. 29–40

Download

Demonstration record: no file is attached.

How to cite

Mensah, K. & Fernandes, J. (2026). Open Peer Review of Machine-Learning Papers: Early Evidence. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Open and Reproducible AI Research (OPENAIR 2026) (pp. 29–40). CONTINUUM Proceedings. doi:10.xxxx/ctm.pr.2026.0014

More from OPENAIR 2026